Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper Reviews – A Complete Buying Guide

Now Reading
Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper Reviews – A Complete Buying Guide

Most of us may have some minor complaints about our existing sleeping mattress. It could be too firm, or it’s slightly worn out that it’s not as comfortable anymore.

However, we are not ready to shell out a huge sum of money to replace the entire mattress just yet. So what’s the ideal solution?

Enter mattress toppers, or more specifically memory foam mattress toppers. They are designed to greatly improve the comfort of your mattress, and the best memory foam mattress toppers can work wonders to enhance your sleep quality tremendously.

However, just as any other products, we are bombarded with a variety of choices when it comes to buying the best memory foam mattress topper. Therefore, this buying guide was written to guide you through the selection process.

When we put together this guide, we look at not just individual memory foam mattress topper reviews, as comfort and sleeping preference can be very subjective from person to person.

To capture the overall user satisfaction and choose the best memory foam mattress topper, a more accurate method is to look at hundreds of customer reviews and conduct in-depth research into the materials used for each mattress to understand what makes them great (or not).

We know most buyers do not have time to look into hundreds of toppers and thousands of reviews, so we have done the homework to find out the best memory foam mattress toppers that will suit most readers in this guide.

We have also written detailed memory foam mattress topper reviews for each of our recommendations, feel free to read them up for more details before deciding on your purchase.

#Mattress TopperReviewRatingPrice GroupsSizesWarranty PeriodCertifications
1Best Comfort Topper
DreamFoam Bedding 2"
dreamfoam gel swirl memory foam mattress topper review
Full Review4.8 stars$$Twin
Twin XL
Full
Full XL
Queen
Short Queen
King
California King
3 YearsCentiPur-US
2Best Cooling Topper
Advanced Sleep Solutions 2"
Advanced Sleep Solutions Gel-Infused 2-Inch Memory Foam Topper review
Full Review4.6 stars$$Twin
Twin XL
Full
Queen
King
California King
3 YearsCentiPur-US
3Best Back Support Topper
Sleep Innovations 4"
sleep innovations dual layer mattress topper review
Full Review4.4 stars$$$Twin
Full
Queen
King
California King
10 YearsCentiPur-US
4Best Budget Topper
LUCID 5-zone 2"
Lucid 2-Inch 5-Zone Lavender Memory Foam Topper
Full Review4.4 stars$Twin
Twin XL
Full
Full XL
Queen
King
California King
3 YearsCentiPur-US
5LinenSpa 2"
Full Review4.6 stars$$Twin
Twin XL
Full
Queen
King
California King
3 YearsCentiPur-US
6Lucid Gel 3"

Full Review4.2 stars$$Twin
Twin XL
Full
Full XL
Queen
King
California King
3 YearsCentiPur-US

 

Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper of 2018:

.

.
BEST COMFORT MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPER
.
EDITOR’S CHOICE:
DREAMFOAM BEDDING GEL SWIRL TOPPER .

dreamfoam gel swirl memory foam mattress topper reviewRATING4.8 stars

PRICE GROUP$$

WARRANTY3 years

MATERIAL: Gel-Infused Memory Foam

THICKNESS: 2-Inches

CERTIFICATION: CentiPUR-US

PROS: Affordable Price Points, Extremely High Customer Rating for Comfort, Minimal Motion Transfer, Cooling Gel Helps with Temperature Regulation

CONS: Tears Relatively Easily, May Release Odors Within First 24 Hours of Unpacking

The Dreamfoam Bedding Gel Swirl Memory Foam Mattress Topper is one of the most recognized and best-rated toppers on the internet.

Unlike traditional memory foam products, the gel-infused open cell structure of Gel Swirl Topper is breathable and dissipates heat away from the sleeper throughout the night.

It is also suitable for those who have trouble staying asleep all night due to movements in the bed (either from a partner or from a pet) thanks to its soft and visco-elastic nature. In other words, it is excellent at absorbing motion transfer.

This topper retains the comfort and “sleeping on a cloud” sensation despite being infused with gel foam. In terms of comfort, it is not that much different from traditional memory foam toppers.

FULL REVIEW ECO TERRA 11" LUXURY LATEX MATTRESS


.
BEST COOLING MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPER
.
EDITOR’S CHOICE:
ADVANCED SLEEP SOLUTIONS GEL-INFUSED 2″ TOPPER .

Advanced Sleep Solutions Gel-Infused 2-Inch Memory Foam Topper reviewRATING4.6 stars

PRICE GROUP$$

WARRANTY3 years

MATERIAL: Gel-Infused Memory Foam

THICKNESS: 2-Inches

CERTIFICATION: CentiPUR-US

PROS: Good Comfort, Exceptional Cooling Capabilities, Fully Manufactured in the States, Motion Transfer Reduction, Higher Density and Better Support than Other 2-Inch Competitors

CONS: Slightly More Expensive than Its 2-Inch Competitors

If you are looking for a relatively lightweight 2-inch cooling topper with slightly better back support than its direct competitors, look no further than the Advanced Sleep Solutions Gel-Infused 2″ Topper.

It has a higher density compared to other 2″ memory foam toppers (3.3 lb. vs <2.5 lb. density), so it is rated as medium-soft instead of soft.

Of course, this also means that it is slightly firmer than traditional memory foam mattress toppers and does not sink as much. However, it is still significantly softer than mattress toppers made of other materials (e.g. latex toppers).

One thing that sets this mattress topper apart is its exceptional cooling capabilities, thanks to its anti-sink surface and gel-infused memory foam.

It doesn’t wrap around the sleeper as much as softer memory foam mattress, which prevents trapping of body heat. Combined with the cooling gel that dissipates heat away, we have a clear winner in the temperature regulation category.

Get this if you want maximum heat dissipation and sleeping hot throughout the night is a big concern for you.

FULL REVIEW ECO TERRA 11" LUXURY LATEX MATTRESS



BEST BACK SUPPORT MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPER
.
EDITOR’S CHOICE:
SLEEP INNOVATIONS 4″ DUAL LAYER MATTRESS TOPPER .

sleep innovations dual layer mattress topper reviewRATING4.4 stars

PRICE GROUP$$$

WARRANTY3 years

MATERIAL: Gel-Infused Memory Foam
MATERIAL: Fiber-Filled Support Layer

THICKNESS: 4-Inches

CERTIFICATION: CentiPUR-US

PROS: Long Warranty Period of 10 Years, Affordable for a Dual-Layer Topper, Sleeps Cool Due to Open-Cell Gel-Infused Foam, Decent Spinal Support Due to Fiber-Filled Layer, Comes with Washable Mattress Topper Cover

CONS: Slightly More Expensive Than Single Layer Competitors, May Release Odors Within First 24 Hours of Unpacking

Decent dual-layer mattress toppers are usually significantly more expensive than their single-layer competitors, but the Sleep Innovations 4″ Topper is surprisingly affordable for the quality it provides.

Due to its double-layer construction, the topper comes with a washable cover that holds both the top gel-infused foam and the bottom fiber-filled support layer together.

Granted, it is not the cheapest topper out there, but the premium you pay gives you a support layer that is not available in most of its direct competitors in the cheaper price range.

Therefore, it is an excellent choice if you want to add comfort to your bed, but at the same time need to support common pressure points such as neck, shoulders, back or stomach.

The top layer is infused with cool gel with open-cell structure, similar to other memory foam mattress toppers with cooling capabilities.

For customers who care about the length of warranty, it is the only memory foam mattress topper on this list that comes with a long 10 years warranty.

FULL REVIEW ECO TERRA 11" LUXURY LATEX MATTRESS


.
BEST BUDGET MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPER
.
EDITOR’S CHOICE:
LUCID 5-ZONE 2″ MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPER .

Lucid 2-Inch 5-Zone Lavender Memory Foam TopperRATING4.4 stars

PRICE GROUP$

WARRANTY3 years

MATERIAL: Lavender Scented Memory Foam

THICKNESS: 2-Inches

CERTIFICATION: CentiPUR-US

PROS: Rock-Bottom Prices, CentiPur-US Certified, Good Score for Comfort, Relieves Pressure Points, Lavender Scent Helps Relaxation

CONS: Lavender Scent Can be Overpowering Upon Unpacking, Temperature Regulation Can be Better

Lucid’s 5-Zone 2″ Memory Foam Mattress Topper has been selected as the best budget mattress topper that you can buy right now.

It stays well below 100 bucks, even for the most expensive California King size. It’s hard to find any other quality memory foam mattress topper with a better price-to-performance ratio.

The Lucid’s 5-Zone 2″ Memory Foam Mattress Topper is excellent at what it is designed to do. Even though it is only 2-inches thick, it softens up a firm mattress surface significantly and provides decent comfort.

Since it is infused with lavender scent, make sure that you are not allergic or overly sensitive to this particular smell. The scent can be overwhelming on the first night, so you may want to air it out in another room for at least 24 hours.

With that being said, it is not infused with cooling gel, nor is it meant to provide extra spinal support. It is designed for users who just want to add a soft layer and enhance comfort of their bed.

If you have specific requirements (extra cooling or spinal support), look at our recommendations below.

FULL REVIEW ECO TERRA 11" LUXURY LATEX MATTRESS


.
LINENSPA 2″ GEL-INFUSED MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPER .

RATING4.6 stars

PRICE GROUP$$

WARRANTY3 years

MATERIAL: Gel-Infused Memory Foam

THICKNESS: 2-Inches

CERTIFICATION: CentiPUR-US

PROS: Highly Affordable, Good Comfort Score, No Odors Upon Unpacking, Gel-Infused Foam is Efficient at Ventilation

CONS: Tears Relatively Easily (As With Most Memory Foam Toppers)

Linenspa 2″ Gel-Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper is a product that ticks most of the important boxes when it comes to buying a decent topper at a relatively affordable price.

It is one of the best foam mattress toppers when it comes to the price-to-performance ratio (it is only slightly more expensive than our budget selection Lucid’s 5-Zone Topper), and it is one of the cheapest toppers infused with cooling gel.

It is commendable that Linenspa does not cut corners when it comes to providing comfort. This topper has been given a high comfort score by its customers, and it exhibits the typical “sinking sensation” of memory foam products.

If you are looking for a budget memory foam topper with cooling capabilities, this might just be your best bet.

FULL REVIEW ECO TERRA 11" LUXURY LATEX MATTRESS


.
LUCID 3″ GEL MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPER .

RATING4.2 stars

PRICE GROUP$$

WARRANTY3 years

MATERIAL: Gel-Infused Memory Foam

THICKNESS: 3-Inches

CERTIFICATION: CentiPUR-US

PROS: Minimal Odor Upon Unpacking, Gel-Infused Foam Keeps It Cool, Excellent at Relieving Pain Points, Slightly Thicker Than Competitors (3″ vs. 2″) in Similar Price Bracket

CONS: Slightly Pricier Than 2″ Competitors

Apart from the best budget memory foam topper (Lucid’s 5-Zone 2″ Topper), Lucid has also produced another excellent topper that makes it into our recommendation list.

The Lucid’s 3″ Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper sits in an interesting spot – it is slightly thicker than its direct competitors, but it is not thick enough to provide extra support for pressure points.

However, due to the extra thickness, it is excellent at relieving and dispersing pressure typically exerted on pressure points such as neck, shoulders and hips.

It doesn’t come with a dedicated support layer like the Advanced Sleep Solution’s 4″ topper, but it is thick enough to provide a noticeable improvement in pain relief.

The gel-infused foam is also excellent at dispersing body heat and keeps the sleeper cool throughout the night.

FULL REVIEW ECO TERRA 11" LUXURY LATEX MATTRESS

 

Best Memory Foam Mattress Toppers: Essential Considerations

 

Terms like mattress toppers, mattress pads and mattress protectors are often used interchangeably as if they are the same products.

In reality, there are slight differences and they are designed for distinct purposes. You can have both a mattress topper and a mattress protector on your bed if you need them.

ProductFunctions
Mattress Topper
mattress topper example
1. Provides an extra layer to existing mattress
2. Improves comfort significantly
3. Generally thicker than a mattress pad
4. Thickness usually range from 2-inches to 4-inches
Mattress Pad
mattress pad example
1. Provides extra padding to existing mattress
2. Keep bed sheets in place
3. Most models are waterproof
4. Helps with regulation of body temperature
Mattress Protector
mattress protector example
1. Can be a casing or a layer on top of existing mattress
2. Protects against liquid and allergens
3. Can be used in conjunction with mattress toppers

 

Generally, mattress toppers and mattress pads are purchased when you want to enhance the comfort of your bed. Memory foam mattress toppers are excellent at softening up a firm mattress surface to improve sleep quality.

On the other hand, mattress protectors are purchased to protect your existing mattress from sweat, spillage and allergens. They are waterproof and hypoallergenic, and they are generally easily removed and cleaned.

Therefore, if you have a slightly worn mattress but you are not ready to replace it just yet, purchasing a mattress topper is an economical way to rejuvenate your bed and save the money you could have spent replacing the whole mattress.

You can also place a mattress topper on of your brand new mattress to protect it from daily wear and tear.

On top of that, if you are allergic to your sleeping surface or just want to protect it against water splashes, you can add a mattress protector, even if you already have a mattress topper.

What that in mind, here are some questions to ask yourself before deciding which is the best memory foam mattress topper for you and your family.
.

BEST MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPERS:

What’s best for one person isn’t necessarily the best for the next. While some users like to get the best bang for their bucks, others prefer to invest a substantial amount of money into their purchases to ensure their sleeping quality and its longevity.

We work hard to detail the strengths and weaknesses of each recommendation we make, so look out for the criteria that are important to you when you read through the guide.
.

THICKNESS OF MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPERS:

Memory foam mattress toppers come in varying sizes and thicknesses, most notably 2 to 4-inches thick. The cheaper variants generally consist of just a single layer and are at most 3-inches thick.

Differences in thickness contribute to varying degree of comfort, heat retention and pain-relief. Generally speaking, thicker memory foam mattress toppers sink your body deeper and cradle around the sleeper more tightly, resulting in better comfort but also tend to sleep hot.

To combat the traditional weakness of sleeping hot, some models use gel-infused foams to help with ventilation.
.

VENTILATION OF MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPERS:

As mentioned above, sleeping hot is a traditional weakness of memory foam products, including mattresses and mattress toppers. While most users love the feeling of “sleeping in a cloud” on a memory foam, it is a double-edged sword.

The more your sleeping surface wraps around your body, the harder it is for your body heat to dissipate and as a result, some users wake up in hot sweats during the night.

If you tend to sleep hot throughout the night, make sure you shop around for gel-infused memory foam mattress toppers. These mattress toppers are constructed using gel foams with open-cell structure, and they dissipate heat away from the sleeper’s body much more effectively than normal memory foam.

The down-side is that they are generally a bit more expensive compared to basic memory foam mattress toppers. But hey, investing a bit more money into a gel-infused foam topper is better than blasting away your air conditioner every single night.

Some excellent memory foam mattress toppers that incorporate gel foam include Advanced Sleep Solutions 2″ (Editor’s Choice for Best Cooling Topper), DreamFoam Bedding 2″Linenspa 2″, Sleep Innovations 4″, and Lucid Gel 3″.
.

DENSITY OF MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPERS:

Memory foam mattress toppers are generally designed to have lower density so they are softer and sink more easily. This property is important to help to relieve pain on common pressure points such as neck, shoulders and hips.

It is important to note that memory foam toppers are not designed to provide more support to your body than your mattress already does.

If your existing mattress is sagging badly and doesn’t provide enough support to your body, it means that the core layers have already broken down and require replacement. In these cases, adding a memory foam mattress topper will not restore its former firmness.

If this description fits your current mattress, it will be better to invest in a decent latex mattress or memory foam mattress that will last for years to come.
.

CERTIFICATION OF MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPERS:

The memory foam mattress topper that you choose should be CentiPur-US certified.

This is a well-established certification to make sure that the product does not contain ozone-depleting chemicals and is regulated by Consumer Product Safety Commissions Low VOC (Volatile Organic Compound) emissions for indoor air quality (less than 0.5 parts per million).

Being CertiPur-US certified also means that the topper does not contain PBDE flame retardants, mercury, lead and heavy metals, as well as formaldehyde and forbidden phthalates that are harmful to you and your family’s health.

All memory foam mattress toppers recommended in this guide are CentiPur-US certified.
.

MOTION TRANSFER REDUCTION OF MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPERS:

Motion transfer reduction refers to the absorption of movements and vibrations on one side of the mattress when there is movement on the other side.

For example, if you are sleeping with a partner or with a pet, how often is your sleep disturbed because they toss and turn in the bed?

A mattress topper with good motion transfer reduction helps to absorb and eliminate movements on the other side of the bed and preserve your sleep quality throughout the night.

The good news is, the best memory foam mattress toppers are often excellent in this regards, so you won’t have a problem with any of the recommendations in this list.
.

SHIPPING METHOD OF MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPERS:

As memory foam mattress toppers are flexible, they are often compressed and shipped in vacuum packaging.

To preserve the structural integrity of the product, allow your topper to expand to its original size before using.

Most memory foam mattress toppers fully expand within 24 to 48 hours, some take lesser time. Refer to the manual that comes together with your purchase for optimal expansion time.
.

PRICES AND WARRANTY OF MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS TOPPERS:

Of course, price is the main driving factor for most people’s purchasing decision, but it is important to focus on the overall build quality, certifications and customer satisfaction as well when it comes to buying a memory foam mattress topper.

This is something that will affect your sleep quality so I recommend that you buy your top choice, testing it out at home, and returning/exchanging it if it doesn’t feel quite right.

If you have settled on a choice, rest assured that most toppers will come with a minimum of 3 years warranty. However, it’s important to read their terms and make sure that you don’t do anything that can void your warranty.

 

How Do We Select the Best Memory Foam Mattress Toppers?

 

After much deliberate considerations, there is no single product that ticks all of the boxes of a perfect memory foam mattress topper.

With all else being equal, we have selected the best memory foam mattress topper in 4 different categories:

  • Best Budget Memory Foam Mattress Topper: Best memory foam mattress topper at the lowest price point.
    .
  • Best Comfort Memory Foam Mattress Topper: Memory foam topper that is rated as the most comfortable by its customers.
    .
  • Best Cooling Memory Foam Mattress Topper: Best gel-infused topper that sleeps cool throughout the night.
    .
  • Best Back Support Memory Foam Mattress Topper: Best thick memory foam mattress topper with a dedicated support layer.
    .

All mattresses featured below do not compromise on the basic requirements, namely affordability, good comfort, motion transfer reduction, adequate safety certification, overall customer satisfaction, as well as support and warranty.

Choose the best memory foam mattress topper based on the criteria that are most important to you.

Memory Foam Mattress Topper Reviews Summary

 

As with most things in life, there’s no one-size-fits-it-all when it comes to selecting the best memory foam mattress topper.

Everyone’s favorite will be different depending on their specific requirements, which is why we have selected the best foam mattress topper in each category.

We recommend that you select the best topper based on the criteria most important to you.

Best in CategoryMattress Topper
BudgetLucid's 5-Zone 2" Topper
ComfortDreamFoam Bedding Gel Swirl Topper
CoolingAdvanced Sleep Solutions Gel-Infused 2" Topper
Body SupportSleep Innovations 4" Dual Layer Topper

Keep in mind that even though it can rejuvenate your bed, a mattress topper is not meant to replace your existing mattress.

If you have an old and sagging mattress, it might be better to invest in a good memory foam mattress instead.